The one kitchen tool professional chefs say is most overrated

Convenient tools don’t always earn space

Professional chefs are surprisingly united about which gadget they consider the most overrated: the garlic press.

Although popular among home cooks, many culinary experts dismiss it as unnecessary, clunky, and limiting. This slideshow explores why chefs avoid garlic presses, what they recommend instead, and how other overrated tools compare.

Why overrated kitchen tools matter

Kitchen gadgets are marketed as time-savers, yet not all live up to the hype.

For chefs, efficiency comes from skill, precision, and multipurpose tools rather than gimmicky inventions. When a gadget does only one job (often less effectively than a knife) it becomes more clutter than help.

The garlic press is a perfect example of a tool praised for convenience but criticized for poor value in professional kitchens.

What is a garlic press?

At first glance, the garlic press looks like a useful helper.

This handheld tool crushes peeled or unpeeled cloves by forcing them through tiny holes, producing a fine garlic paste. It’s marketed as a shortcut that saves time, spares your fingers from strong odors, and eliminates the need for chopping.

But while it seems efficient, chefs argue its single-purpose design makes it far less practical than a trusty knife.

Why people use garlic presses

For many home cooks, the garlic press feels like a lifesaver. It promises instant minced garlic with one squeeze, keeping your hands relatively clean. With garlic being a staple in countless recipes, it’s no surprise that presses are common in kitchens.

Yet this supposed convenience comes at a cost—less durability, more cleanup, and no versatility compared to other tools. That’s why professional chefs remain skeptical of its true value.

Professional chefs’ take on garlic presses

Celebrity chef Ina Garten has famously dismissed the garlic press, preferring her knife.

She and other professionals argue that a sharp blade delivers more control, better texture, and greater efficiency in the long run. Why dedicate drawer space to a single-function tool when a knife can do it all?

For chefs, versatility wins every time, and the garlic press doesn’t measure up against fundamental knife skills.

Downsides of garlic presses

Garlic presses aren’t just limited, they’re also impractical. Many models are awkward to clean, with garlic bits clogging the small holes. Some even bend or break when used for tougher ingredients like ginger.

In professional kitchens, where durability and speed are crucial, these flaws make garlic presses more hassle than help. Chefs see them as fragile gadgets that complicate tasks better handled by tools already in use.

The knife alternative

The chef’s knife is the ultimate alternative to a garlic press. A few quick chops can yield minced garlic in seconds, with far more control over texture. Want a fine paste? Sprinkle salt and smash the garlic under the knife blade.

Beyond garlic, that same knife slices onions, dices tomatoes, or carves meat. Its versatility makes it an essential in every professional kitchen, unlike a single-task press.

Skill over gadgetry

Chefs emphasize that developing knife skills pays off more than relying on gadgets. Mastering basic techniques (such as dicing, mincing, and crushing) improves safety, precision, and speed. These skills translate across countless ingredients, not just garlic.

A garlic press might offer a shortcut, but knife skills empower cooks to work confidently with any produce. For professionals, knowledge in the hand is always more valuable than metal in the drawer.

Kitchen minimalism

A cluttered kitchen slows cooks down, while minimalism keeps things flowing.

Chefs prefer multipurpose tools because they save space, last longer, and serve multiple roles in cooking. Instead of drawers full of single-use gadgets, they rely on versatile items like knives, spoons, and sturdy pans.

The garlic press symbolizes the opposite: a bulky object with one limited job. Minimalist kitchens simply don’t have room for such redundancy.

Other overrated kitchen tools

The garlic press isn’t alone in receiving criticism from chefs. Mandolins, though precise, are risky and time-consuming to clean. Onion holders are gimmicky, offering little that a knife can’t do better. Oil misters clog easily and rarely spray evenly, making them frustrating in practice.

These tools often sound helpful but quickly become drawer clutter. For professionals, focusing on a few essentials always outshines stockpiling trendy gadgets.

What professional chefs actually use

Rather than relying on single-purpose gadgets, chefs stick to timeless essentials.

A razor-sharp chef’s knife tops the list, followed by quality cutting boards, durable pans, and everyday utensils like spoons, tongs, and spatulas. These tools withstand heavy use, adapt to multiple tasks, and support consistency in cooking.

In the fast pace of a professional kitchen, efficiency is about simplicity—not gadgets that solve problems knives already handle with ease.

Chefs’ quotes on garlic presses

Professional chefs rarely mince words about garlic presses.

Ina Garten once said, “I never use a garlic press; I always have a knife handy.” Her perspective is echoed by others who believe gadgets can’t replace good technique. Chef Masaharu Morimoto has also criticized unnecessary tools, praising skill instead.

These voices highlight a common theme: cooking is more about knowledge and practice than owning every gadget sold.

Practical kitchen tips

Want to skip the garlic press without losing efficiency?

Start with a sharp knife—dull blades slow you down and increase risk. For pastes, try a mortar and pestle, which also releases deeper flavors. A microplane grater works beautifully when you want airy, finely textured garlic.

With these methods, you gain versatility, control, and flavor, proving that thoughtful technique beats gadget dependence every time.

Maintenance and longevity

Durability is another reason chefs dismiss garlic presses. Over time, they bend, clog, or break, turning into wasted money and clutter. Cleaning them is often a messy chore, especially compared to quickly rinsing a knife.

A well-maintained chef’s knife, however, can last decades with proper sharpening and care. For both professionals and home cooks, investing in fewer, better tools pays off in convenience and reliability.

Alternatives to garlic presses

If you’re ready to ditch the garlic press, you have plenty of options.

A sharp knife provides control for mincing or smashing cloves. A microplane creates fine, delicate shreds perfect for dressings. Meanwhile, a mortar and pestle produces smooth pastes ideal for marinades or sauces.

Each method offers versatility that a press simply cannot match, while enhancing the flavors and textures of your favorite garlic-rich dishes. Also, check out why your air fryer smells. Here are top tips to keep it fresh.

If you’re choosing where to invest in kitchen tools, go simple

Buy a high-quality chef’s knife and keep it sharp. Practice knife skills regularly, and you’ll soon work faster than with most gadgets. Add a few multipurpose essentials, and your cooking will feel more effortless.

Chefs remind us: less clutter, more control. Let the garlic press go, and embrace tools that truly elevate your cooking experience. Also check out celebrity chefs reveal their best-kept kitchen secrets.

Do you agree with the chefs, or do you love this tool? Tell us your most overrated kitchen gadget!

Get more kitchen related tips here:

• The Crispy Hacks Every Air Fryer Owner Should Try
• Why Your Air Fryer Meals Aren’t Crispy (Easy Fix)
• Stop Freezing Bread like this Immediately

If you liked this article, you’ll LOVE our free email newsletter.

This slideshow was made with AI assistance and human editing.