Lionel Messi’s favorite pizza topping is dividing fans for an unexpected reason

Lionel Messi’s unusual pizza order divides fans

Lionel Messi shared the Banchero Miami pizza on Instagram in September 2023, and the order resurfaced online in July 2026, renewing the debate over its unconventional appearance.

The restaurant’s Napolitana combines mozzarella, tomato sauce, sliced tomatoes, onion, chimichurri, garlic, oregano, and olives, creating a distinctive appearance that drew sharply divided reactions online.

The reaction reaches beyond food into fan culture, regional traditions, and personal taste. It also shows how an unfamiliar pizza style can attract strong opinions when viewed outside its original culinary context.

Why do fans care so much?

Supporters often notice small details about famous athletes. Food choices can become part of a celebrity’s public image, encouraging fans to compare preferences in comment sections and social media posts.

Many sports stars become connected with routines and traditions. Those habits help fans feel closer to everyday life.

Pizza naturally becomes part of that familiar picture because everyday food choices often make world-famous athletes seem more relatable beyond their sporting achievements.

What Messi’s pizza actually included

Messi’s order matches Banchero’s Napolitana, which the restaurant describes as mozzarella and tomato sauce topped with sliced tomatoes, onion, chimichurri, garlic, oregano, and olives.

The toppings reflect Banchero’s Argentine menu rather than a typical American pizza combination. Whole olives, sliced tomatoes, onion, and prominent herbs also help explain why the order looked unfamiliar to some international viewers.

Why the combination looked unusual

To viewers expecting a familiar American-style pizza, the large tomato slices, onion rings, whole green olives, and visible herbs appeared unconventional. The same toppings are less surprising within Buenos Aires pizza culture, where olives and onion-forward combinations are widely established.

The reaction, therefore, reflects a difference in regional expectations. What some viewers interpreted as an unusual celebrity order is recognizable as an Argentine-style combination to diners familiar with the country’s pizzerias.

Taste often reflects routine

Messi shared the pizza while missing Inter Miami’s September 2023 match against Atlanta United. After Atlanta won 5–2, the club referenced the pizza in a social-media post, extending the discussion from food preferences into football rivalry.

The attention also benefited Banchero Miami. Contemporary reports described increased public interest in the restaurant after Messi featured its pizza on Instagram.

Banchero’s roots go back to 1932

Banchero’s history provides important context for the order. Juan Banchero opened the traditional pizzeria in Buenos Aires’ La Boca neighborhood with his sons Tito and Antonio on March 28, 1932.

The business became closely associated with the city’s pizza culture, particularly onion-forward styles linked with fugazza and fugazzetta. That history helps explain why prominent onions and olives do not appear unusual on its menu.

Little-known fact: Virginia’s famous country cured ham is considered among America’s finest, prized for its dark, lean texture and rich traditional flavor profile.

The conversation keeps growing

The discussion says as much about fans as it does about pizza. Personal food favorites often inspire friendly disagreement. That keeps the topic entertaining instead of serious while giving supporters another reason to connect through everyday conversations.

Whether someone prefers ham or another topping, the debate reflects individual taste. Messi continues attracting attention both on and off the field. Even a pizza order can become part of sports culture, showing how small personal details often become memorable parts of a global sports icon’s public image.

Why regional pizza traditions matter

Buenos Aires pizza is often thicker and more cheese-heavy than many familiar U.S. styles. The city’s official tourism guide also notes that its traditional mozzarella pizza is commonly served with an olive on each portion.

“Banchero’s Napolitana builds on that regional approach with sliced tomato, onion, garlic, oregano, chimichurri, and olives over sauce and mozzarella. Its appearance may be striking, but its ingredients fit the restaurant’s Argentine identity.

Fun fact: Messi’s favorite pizza comes from Banchero, a family-run Argentine pizzeria whose original Buenos Aires location has served customers since 1932.

The name can cause confusion

Banchero calls the pizza a Napolitana, but the name should not be confused with traditional Neapolitan pizza from Naples. In Argentina, Napolitana can describe a topping combination featuring cheese, tomato slices, garlic, oregano, and olives.

Traditional Neapolitan pizza follows a different preparation style, including a soft base and raised outer edge. Banchero’s version belongs to the Argentine pizza tradition represented across its menu.

Home cooks can recreate the topping profile

A home version inspired by the order can combine pizza dough, tomato sauce, mozzarella, sliced tomatoes, thinly sliced onion, garlic, oregano, green olives, and a small amount of chimichurri.

Because Banchero does not publish its complete preparation method in the menu description, a homemade version should be identified as inspired by the restaurant rather than presented as an exact copy. Baking time should follow the instructions for the selected dough or crust.

Small details shape flavor

Tomato slices, onion, and chimichurri can add considerable moisture to a homemade pizza. Using thin tomato slices and a light amount of chimichurri can help prevent the toppings from overwhelming the crust.

Whole green olives preserve the appearance associated with the Banchero order, while garlic and oregano reinforce the savory flavor profile listed on the restaurant’s menu.

A conversation beyond sports

The lasting appeal of the discussion comes from its simplicity. Everyone has a favorite pizza combination worth defending. That common experience connects sports fans and food lovers alike.

A single meal preference can become a memorable part of a public image. The conversation remains friendly because taste is personal. That keeps the focus on enjoyment instead of competition while reminding fans that even global sports icons share ordinary food preferences that many people can relate to.

These 9 frozen pizzas use surprisingly premium ingredients that could change how you approach quick dinners and everyday grocery shopping.

Every slice tells a story

Messi continues inspiring conversations that reach beyond football. Even a favorite pizza topping can remind people that global stars enjoy familiar comforts.

The discussion shows there is no perfect pizza for everyone. Personal taste remains the best reason to choose one topping over another.

The eating habits that keep Lionel Messi match-ready, from breakfast routines to game day meals, offer another fascinating side of his career.

What topping would you choose for your perfect pizza? Share your thoughts in the comments.

This slideshow was made with AI assistance and human editing.

Don’t forget to follow us for more exclusive content right here on MSN.

Read more from here:

• These are the 5 new fast food BBQ items I would spend my own money on in 2026 without hesitation
• Amazon Fresh’s newest grocery finds are worth adding to your watchlist
• Minions meet dessert in Sam’s Club’s sweetest new launch yet