Jimmy John’s just launched cheesy new sandwiches, here’s what to expect

Jimmy John’s gets toasted and cheesy

For a limited time, customers can enjoy two pizza-inspired sandwiches at Jimmy John’s that combine everything people love about melty cheese and bold Italian flavors.

These subs bring together gooey mozzarella, zesty marinara, and freshly baked bread. Here’s everything you need to know about this crave-worthy launch.

Jimmy John’s new menu launch

In September 2025, Jimmy John’s rolled out two limited-time toasted pizza sandwiches nationwide. This marks a bold step in menu innovation, introducing hot, melty options to a brand traditionally known for cold subs.

The launch highlights the company’s effort to compete with other fast-casual restaurants offering toasted or pizza-inspired sandwiches. Customers can now get a satisfying cheese-filled option that blends comfort food flavors with Jimmy John’s signature speedy service.

The concept behind the launch

The toasted pizza sandwiches were designed to capture the best of two worlds—pizza and subs.

Served on Jimmy John’s fresh-baked French bread, each sandwich comes loaded with melted cheeses, tangy marinara, and carefully chosen toppings. The result is a handheld meal that feels indulgent yet familiar.

By leaning into pizza flavors, Jimmy John’s is tapping into a universal comfort favorite, but presenting it in their own quick-service, sandwich-focused way.

The two new sandwiches

Jimmy John’s has released two new toasted pizza sandwiches to appeal to different tastes.

The Toasted Sicilian Pizza Sandwich is a meaty, Sicilian-inspired creation layered with Italian cold cuts, cheese, and herbs. Meanwhile, the Toasted Three Cheese Pizza Sandwich focuses entirely on gooey, melted cheese, making it a perfect choice for vegetarians and cheese lovers alike. Both options showcase Jimmy John’s ability to reinvent comfort food in sandwich form.

Toasted Sicilian Pizza Sandwich

The Toasted Sicilian Pizza Sandwich packs bold flavors into every bite.

It features salami, capocollo, ham, and sliced mozzarella layered on toasted French bread, then finished with marinara sauce, oregano, and basil. The flavor profile is hearty, savory, and slightly spicy, delivering a taste of Sicily in a handheld form. Perfect for meat lovers, it balances the richness of cured meats with the tangy kick of marinara and herbs.

Toasted Three Cheese Pizza Sandwich

For cheese enthusiasts, the Toasted Three Cheese Pizza Sandwich is a dream.

Stacked with mozzarella, provolone, and parmesan, this vegetarian-friendly option offers maximum gooeyness and flavor. Zesty marinara sauce, oregano, and basil complete the experience, giving every bite a pizza-like quality.

The mix of creamy and slightly sharp cheeses makes this sandwich rich yet balanced. It’s Jimmy John’s first vegetarian toasted option, expanding the menu to include something indulgent for non-meat eaters.

Bread and toasting method

Jimmy John’s fresh-baked French bread is the foundation of these new sandwiches.

Each loaf is toasted until golden, adding crunch while warming the fillings. This step transforms their signature soft bread into a crispy, hearty base that holds up against the gooey cheeses and rich marinara sauce.

The toasting process creates layers of texture, ensuring every bite delivers both satisfying crunch and melty softness inside.

Cheese pull sensation

Few things excite food lovers like a dramatic cheese pull, and these sandwiches deliver.

Each bite stretches with gooey ribbons of mozzarella, provolone, or parmesan, creating the perfect Instagram-worthy moment. Jimmy John’s cleverly leans into this viral food trend, making the sandwiches both fun and indulgent.

The cheese pull isn’t just for looks—it enhances the eating experience, offering melty richness that pairs perfectly with the crispy toasted bread.

Marinara sauce quality

The marinara sauce plays a starring role in both new sandwiches.

Jimmy John’s uses a tangy, tomato-based sauce with hints of garlic and herbs, designed to cut through the richness of the melted cheeses. Its bright acidity balances the heavier flavors of salami or provolone, ensuring the sandwiches don’t feel overly heavy.

This zesty, flavorful marinara ties everything together, delivering the unmistakable taste of pizza within a sandwich format.

Availability and size options

The toasted pizza sandwiches launched nationwide on September 8, 2025. Fans can order them in two sizes: the classic 8-inch sandwich or the giant 16-inch option for a shareable feast.

Customers can also enjoy these sandwiches in combo meals, paired with Jimmy John’s chips, cookies, or drinks. This flexibility makes it easy to enjoy a quick solo meal or a larger indulgence, depending on your appetite.

Pricing

The new toasted pizza sandwiches start at around $9.09.

Prices may vary by location, but they remain competitive with Jimmy John’s other premium subs. Given the generous portions of meats, cheeses, and freshly baked bread, customers are getting strong value for the price.

Combo options with sides and drinks increase convenience, offering full meals at accessible price points. The cost reflects a balance of indulgence, quality, and affordability for everyday dining.

Customization options

Like other Jimmy John’s offerings, these sandwiches allow customization.

Customers can add or remove toppings, request extra cheese, or substitute ingredients to match their preferences. While the Sicilian comes packed with meats, lighter eaters may opt for fewer layers or add vegetables for balance.

Cheese lovers can double down on melty mozzarella or parmesan. This flexibility ensures the new toasted pizza sandwiches fit a wide range of tastes and cravings.

Toasted sandwich platform expansion

Earlier in 2025, Jimmy John’s introduced toasted sandwiches to diversify its menu. This new pizza-inspired launch expands on that success, pushing the chain further into warm, melty comfort food. It’s a clever response to consumer demand for heartier, indulgent options.

By blending their fresh-baked bread with gooey cheeses and classic Italian flavors, Jimmy John’s positions itself as more than a cold-sandwich shop—it’s becoming a destination for hot, satisfying creations.

Early reviews show excitement

Food bloggers and fans praise the bold cheesy flavors and authentic pizza vibe. Many highlight the vegetarian option as a refreshing addition that broadens appeal.

The gooey cheese pull has been a social media hit, sparking viral posts. Critics note that the concept cleverly captures comfort food in a handheld form, giving Jimmy John’s customers something playful and crave-worthy.

Recreating the Sicilian pizza sandwich at home

To make your own version, start with fresh French bread or a baguette.

Layer slices of salami, capocollo, and ham, then top with mozzarella. Add a few spoonfuls of marinara sauce, sprinkle oregano and basil, and press the sandwich together. Toast in the oven at 200°C (400°F) until the bread is golden and the cheese melts.

It’s a hearty, homemade twist on Jimmy John’s Sicilian favorite, like Betty Crocker’s retro cheese sandwich casserole.

Recreating the three cheese pizza sandwich at home

For the vegetarian option, slice a loaf of fresh French bread lengthwise.

Spread marinara sauce generously, then layer mozzarella, provolone, and parmesan. Sprinkle dried oregano and basil, and close the sandwich. Toast in the oven until the bread is crispy and the cheese stretches with that perfect pull.

This simple recipe captures the melty indulgence of Jimmy John’s three cheese sandwich like the ‘unhealthy’ brunch burger going viral (would you try it?).

Tried the new cheesy sandwiches yet? Tell us your favorite or if you think they’re worth the hype!

Get to know more about delicious sandwiches:

• 15 high protein, low fat sandwiches to make now
• We ranked 10 Potbelly sandwiches, see the best
• How to Nail the Perfect Grilled Cheese Sandwich

If you liked this article, you’ll LOVE our free email newsletter.

This slideshow was made with AI assistance and human editing.