Air Fryer Pop Tarts (Yummy)

With these homemade air fryer pop tarts, your kids will be eager to leave bed! These pop tarts have a flaky, crunchy crust, a soft, sweet filling, and frosting on top. 

We all agree that breakfast is the most significant meal of the day and a family favorite. With a breakfast casserole or eggs and bacon, these air fryer pop tarts go fantastically. The entire family will go nuts for these pop tarts from the air fryer. Children can even assist because they are so simple to construct. 

Even more, expediency is achieved by using prefabricated pie dough. Pop-tarts were always a wonderful treat when I was a kid. When you create them at home in your air fryer, they are now even more wonderful. 

These pop tarts are air-fried to the ultimate pastry crispness. Opening a box from the supermarket is just as simple and quick, but these handmade pop tarts taste so much better. You won’t ever need to buy them again with their hooey gooey delicious contents, crisp flaky crusts, and a sprinkling of frosting.

Why You’ll Love This Recipe?

The store-bought toaster pastries can be replaced with these homemade air fryer pop-tarts for a delicious and amazing alternative. 

They are ideal for breakfast or dessert because they cook quickly and require little preparation. These pop tarts are great on their own since they are loaded with a sweet jam.

However, if you want to decorate them, you can add berry frosting, salted caramel, drizzled chocolate syrup, or cream cheese colored with food coloring for more color.

Things You Feel Need to Make Air Fryer Pop Tarts

Pop TartsYou can use any flavor or brand as long as it is comparable in size to the traditional branded pop tart. You will need to increase or decrease the cooking time to take into consideration if it is smaller, larger, or thicker
Air FryerEither a tray-style air fryer or a basket-style air fryer can be used
Ingredients you will need to make air fryer pop tarts.

How to Make Air Fryer Pop Tarts?

You’ll wonder why you haven’t tried making pop tarts in an air fryer sooner because they are so simple to make. 

You’re going to adore this if, like me, you don’t keep your toaster on your countertop but do keep your air fryer there. Start by bringing your air fryer’s temperature up to 400°F for at least three minutes, or as directed by the manufacturer. 

Place the pop tarts in the basket in a single layer. You can probably accommodate 2-3 at once if you have a 6-quart basket model. Depending on the size of your air fryer, you could probably cook 4-6 at a time if you have a tray style. Cook the edges for 2 to 3 minutes, or until they are just browned and heated through. 

Check it after two minutes and put it back in the air fryer if you don’t think it’s browned enough. Pop tarts will take longer to cook (about 3-5 minutes) if you don’t preheat your air fryer and add them cold. However, preheating is always a good idea.

Edges should be cooked for 2 minutes till they get brown.
Edges should be cooked for 2 minutes till they get brown.

Tips for Making Air Fryer Pop Tarts

Here’re some amazing tips to help you make air fryer pop tarts:

  • Make careful you always pre-heat your air fryer. Although it’s generally advised to wait at least 3 minutes, some models offer a preheat button that can be utilized as a quick alternative. 
  • In the air fryer, never stack or layer your food. This delays the complete cooking of the food and may result in an abundance of moisture in the oven’s basket. Place everything in an equal layer, leaving some space between each item, if you want your meal to be crisp, beautifully browned, and well-cooked.
  • When taking out the basket and placing it on the counter, use a trivet. You don’t want to burn your kitchen counter by setting a hot basket straight on the surface.

How Long Does it Take to Make Pop-Tarts in Air Fryer?

Depending on how many pop tarts you have in your basket and the layout of your air fryer, the frying time may change. 

There will always be a small variation across brands and models. Overall, you want the crust to be nicely golden and the filling to be thoroughly cooked. For me, three to four minutes always work. 

I simply advise monitoring them and trying until you find the ideal timing. Take it as an excuse to keep eating pop tarts from the air fryer!

How Many Pop-Tarts Can You Make at a Time?

This will depend on how big your air fryer is. Cook as many as you can fit in the air fryer basket in a single layer. 

Given how rapidly they cook, it is simple to prepare many batches at once to prevent crowding and yet have breakfast ready in 10 or 15 minutes. 

Depending on the size and shape of the basket, there might be some overlap, but that’s alright. The primary concern is ensuring that hot air can flow around each pop tart. In this manner, the icing will melt and the cookies will get toasty on all sides.

Tricks for Making Perfect Pop Tarts in Air Fryer

Pop tarts are incredibly simple to make in an air fryer. The fact that it takes a little longer than your toaster may not bother you because these are so much nicer. 

  • No two air fryers are the same, as is the case with all appliances. It’s crucial to understand how your air fryer functions. You are allowed to change the time and temperature as necessary. This is just the beginning. Watch how your air fryer bakes the first batch you prepare to learn more about these fantastic pop tarts.
  • Before air frying the pop tarts, make sure to poke holes in the dough. This permits the internal steam to escape and prevents the dough from bubbling up, allowing the crust to cook more uniformly. 
  • Don’t cram too many pop tarts into the air fryer; leave enough room between each one to allow for even cooking from the circulating air. Cook them in batches if necessary. 
  • Leave an Edge: You’ll need to leave an edge so you can properly seal your pop tarts. The filling should not leak all over the air fryer.
  • Leftovers can be stored in the refrigerator for up to five days in a sealed container. up to four months by freezing. Thaw the frozen air fryer pop tarts before reheating. Place in the air fryer for three minutes at 360 degrees.
Make sure to poke holes in your pop-tarts to prevent any bubbling.
Make sure to poke holes in your pop-tarts to prevent any bubbling.

How to Store Air Fryer Pop-Tarts?

  • Poptarts can be kept for up to 3 days at room temperature if they are placed in an airtight container. They can also stay in the fridge for 6-7 days. 
  • Reheat your pop tarts in the air fryer for 1-2 minutes at 300 degrees Fahrenheit.

Why Will You Enjoy Air Fryer Pop Tarts?

These homemade air fryer pop-tarts are a delicious alternative to store-bought toaster pastries. They are ideal for breakfast or dessert because they cook quickly and require little preparation.

These pop tarts are great on their own since they are loaded with a sweet jam. Toppings can include salted caramel, drizzled chocolate syrup, fruit icing, or a splash of food coloring in cream cheese for added color.

Can These Homemade Pop Tarts Be Frozen?

You can definitely keep these pop-tarts in the refrigerator.

They may be consumed too quickly to freeze, but if there are leftovers or you have created extra, they can be frozen. Freeze homemade pop tarts for up to 3 months in an airtight sealed storage bag or container. Thaw and reheat at 350°F for 6-8 minutes, or until warmed through and crispy.


  • An air fryer is a fantastic tool! A small air fryer oven or basket design is now proudly displayed on the countertop in many houses thanks to its recent surge in popularity. And although some of us give it a try and fall in love with it right once, others struggle to utilize it and end up leaving it unused.
  • This tiny gadget is capable of so much, and the best part is that it won’t overheat your home as an oven would. 
  • As we can see these toaster pastries, also serves as a substitute for a toaster. Making toast, bagels, pop tarts, and even waffles in the air fryer is great if you like to keep your toaster out of sight.
  • Before air frying the pop-tarts, make sure to cut slits on top of the dough. This enables the internal steam to escape, prevents the dough from bubbling up, and promotes more equal cooking of the crust. 
  • Whether the glaze is present or not, these pop tarts are excellent. 
  • Use 12 tablespoons of pie filling rather than 1 tablespoon if you prefer flatter pop tarts. Pop-tarts will resemble pastries more if there is more pie filling added. 
  • Make sure the air fryer isn’t crowded. For them to become crispy, make sure there is adequate space for the air to flow.

Other Articles

Scroll to Top
Skip to content